Buzzing The Net

Saint John Sea Dogs’ Jonathan Huberdeau sets off controversy with borderline hit (VIDEO)

Neate Sager
Buzzing The Net

View photo


Saint John Sea Dogs captain Jonathan Huberdeau (Richard Wolowicz, Getty Images)

Depending on how viral the video below goes, Jonathan Huberdeau could be public enemy No. 1 among his home province's junior hockey fans by the time the President's Cup final begins.

The Saint John Sea Dogs captain might have got away with one during the first shift of his team's eventual series-clinching 4-3 overtime win over the Chicoutimi Saguenéens in their QMJHL semifinal series on Saturday night. Just 18 seconds into the contest, Huberdeau knocked one of the top Saguenéens forwards, centre Charles Hudon, out of the game with a questionable check along the boards. On some nights there might have been charging or checking from behind penalty, but in a game where old-school playoff-style officiating seemed to be in place, referees Jonathan Langille and Mario Maillet saw fit to call nothing. It also appears Hudon might have turned toward the boards at the last moment before the collision.

Here's the Sea Dogs video (stick tap for the find to Chris Phillips):

As you might expect, the a clamour for Huberdeau to be suspended could break across team allegiance and regional lines. (The Saguenéens' Facebook post of the video got 30 comments within two hours, which is a lot on a Sunday morning.)

The late camera switch keeps the full extent of the check from being evident, but it looks like some infraction could have been whistled. But similar plays often result in only a two-minute minor penalty or a double minor, not supplemental discipline. With tongue only half in cheek, if the Cameron Critchlow suspension is any indication, Huberdeau ought to be in the clear. After all, the "evidence has to be overwhelming that the officials erred" (Willy Palov's phrasing) for the QMJHL to reverse a dubious penalty. Then the same standard should apply when it's a dubious no-call, one would think.

The league has issued suspensions previously for incidents that weren't penalized by game officials, that being said. It's worth revisiting the rationale for upholding Critchlow's automatic one-game suspension that will keep him out of Game 6 of the Rimouski-Halifax series, where his Mooseheads are facing a do-or-done game.

Despite the Mooseheads' position, [QMJHL disciplinary prefect Raymond] Bolduc said the standard for overturning that kind of on-ice call is that the evidence has to be overwhelming that the officials erred.

"If it is clear on the video that a player is not doing that, we can reverse that," Bolduc said. "But it was called by the referees and the linesmen. They are both positive that he removed the helmet. It's clear so I have no choice." (Halifax Chronicle-Herald)

This wasn't called by the officials. A day later, are they positive it was a suspendable offence?

There's likely to be some knee-jerking about special treatment for a star player. However, if the officials were giving any Huberdeau any breaks, they had a funny show of showing it. Both he and Chicoutimi's Andrew O'Brien were sent off for roughing in overtime, which led to a 4-on-4 that helped Washington Capitals prospect Stanislav Galiev score Saint John's the series-winning goal.

Ultimately, the QMJHL has a controversy on its hands ahead of the final, since the overdog Sea Dogs will likely not be a media darling as they attempt to make it a Maritime President's Cup three-peat. It's a bit of awkward situation for the league to have a marquee player in the spotlight for a sketchy play. It's almost like the NHL in that regard.

Neate Sager is a writer for Yahoo! Canada Sports. Contact him at and follow him on Twitter @neatebuzzthenet.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Hamilton off the hook as Mercedes start driver search

      Hamilton off the hook as Mercedes start driver search

      By Alan Baldwin LONDON (Reuters) - Mercedes will not punish triple world champion Lewis Hamilton for defying orders at the season-ending Abu Dhabi Formula One Grand Prix, the team's non-executive chairman Niki Lauda has said. In the wake of team … More »

      Reuters - 35 minutes ago
    • Jones changing England through evolution, not revolution

      Jones changing England through evolution, not revolution

      By Mitch Phillips LONDON (Reuters) - The most remarkable aspect of the turnaround in England's fortunes over the last 12 months is that on the surface so little seems to have changed. Eddie Jones inherited a squad shorn of confidence after being … More »

      Reuters - 42 minutes ago
    • Role is to restore United DNA and build future, says Mourinho

      Role is to restore United DNA and build future, says Mourinho

      (Reuters) - Manager Jose Mourinho said his job was to restore Manchester United's DNA and build the future for the club, which has struggled after the trophy-laden 26-year spell under former boss Alex Ferguson. Despite several promising … More »

      Reuters - 51 minutes ago
    • Hirscher leads France challenge in WCup giant slalom 1st run

      Hirscher leads France challenge in WCup giant slalom 1st run

      VAL D'ISERE, France (AP) -- It was course specialist Marcel Hirscher vs. the home France team in the opening run of a World Cup giant slalom on Sunday. Austria's Hirscher, who won four of the past five GS races at Val d'Isere, was .01 second faster … More »

      AP - Sports - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
    • Red-hot Madrid celebrates 'win' over Barcelona at Camp Nou

      Red-hot Madrid celebrates 'win' over Barcelona at Camp Nou

      Things couldn't be going much better for Real Madrid. Madrid was celebrating Saturday's 1-1 draw against Barcelona at Camp Nou, which kept the team with a comfortable advantage over its rival atop the Spanish league. ''This point feels like a … More »

      AP - Sports - 1 hour 23 minutes ago