Roto Arcade

Spin Doctors: Joe Nathan vs. Addison Reed

Scott Pianowski
Roto Arcade

View photo


Famous Nathan (USAT)

You want us to disagree. You want us to fight. You want us to wrestle in the snow. With that, we Doctor on. Today's assignment: a couple of new-city closers, those handshake guys.

Pianow stumps for Nathan: Okay, maybe closer debates aren't at the Bird/Magic filibuster level. Maybe I'm just curious what my buddy Del Don has against Joe Nathan. If industry consensus means anything to you (and I'm not offended if it doesn't), this is an open-and-shut case.

Nathan had the better year than Addison Reed in 2013, no argument there. A 1.39 ERA and 0.897 WHIP, 43 handshakes, better than a strikeout per inning. Not even Ron Washington could screw this up. Reed had two less saves. an ERA in the high 3s, a WHIP over 1.10, a lesser strikeout rate. Even if you want to play the pretend ERA game with FIP and xFIP (or similar), Nathan is comfortably ahead.

[Baseball 2014 from Yahoo! Fantasy Sports: Join a league today!]

Nathan beat the kid by a considerable margin in 2012, too. Yes, we're in the projection business (looking ahead) more than the history business (looking back) - but I can't see why anyone would want to take a leap of faith in Reed's skills sailing past Nathan this year.

Nathan's now in Detroit, Reed in Arizona. Score one for the veteran: tamer park, better supporting cast. I concede predicting save chances is a bit of a fool's errand, but when in doubt I want the team expected to win more games. Detroit's pegged for 89.5 victories this year, nine more than the Snakes.

Nathan's obviously 14 years older, but show me any sign of a decline (the numbers don't show it). Okay, D3, unveil what we're missing.

Del Don calls for Reed: Nathan is coming off a fantastic season, and I admittedly should probably bump him up my closer rankings. However, he’s 39 years old and finished last season with his lowest average fastball velocity (92.2 mph) of his career. This resulted in Nathan using his slider (35.4%) more often than ever. He has a fantastic (and much longer) track record, but Nathan isn’t without risk entering a decline phase approaching age 40.

Reed, on the other hand, is 25 years old and coming off a season in which he recorded a 24.4 K% and an 11.0 SwStr%. He finished with a 1.11 WHIP while pitching in an extreme hitter’s park. Chase Field is one as well, but the move to the National League should help.

For what it’s worth (probably not much), the Tigers produced just 55 save opportunities last season, which were the fewest in the American League. Meanwhile, the Diamondbacks produced 67 save opportunities, which was the sixth most in all of baseball.

I’ve already conceded I currently have Nathan too low, but I’d rather be a year too early than a year too late with an older pitcher with a lot of mileage on his arm. Reed’s best seasons lie ahead of him, and even if you think I’m crazy saying he’ll outperform Nathan in 2014, at least he’s typically much cheaper, with an ADP of about 40 picks later.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Matthews remembers Cubs' failures

      Matthews remembers Cubs' failures

      Once in a while, Gary Matthews relives how close his Chicago Cubs came to reaching the World Series. With his former team just one win from its first World Series trip since 1945, fans everywhere already are envisioning the excitement at Wrigley … More »

      AP - Sports - 2 hours 1 minute ago
    • 10/21/16: FastCast

      10/21/16: FastCast

      Terry Francona discusses the Indians' preparation for the World Series, plus Kyle Hendricks and Clayton Kershaw discuss Game 6 of the NLCS … More » - 3 hours ago
    • LEADING OFF: Cubs face Kershaw, try to end Series drought

      LEADING OFF: Cubs face Kershaw, try to end Series drought

      It's been 71 years since the Chicago Cubs reached the World Series. Anticipating a long-awaited pennant, excited fans at jam-packed Wrigley Field will certainly be on the edge of their seats. Standing in the way of a huge Cubs party is rested … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 hours ago
    • Indians fans buy Merritt wedding gifts

      Indians fans buy Merritt wedding gifts

      The guest list for Ryan Merritt's upcoming wedding could be growing. Cleveland's rookie pitcher has made a lot of new friends. A most improbable October hero for the Indians, Merritt has been overwhelmed by the generous outpouring from some … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 hours ago
    • Indians hoping Danny Salazar will be ready for World Series

      Indians hoping Danny Salazar will be ready for World Series

      Danny Salazar is working his way toward a return in the World Series. According to manager Terry Francona, the All-Star right-hander threw a two-inning simulated game on Sunday that went according to plan. Salazar is scheduled to throw another … More »

      Big League Stew - 4 hours ago