What's Buzzing:

55 Yard Line

Fining Calvillo’s about the action, not the man, and that’s a positive step for the CFL

Andrew Bucholtz
55 Yard Line

View photo


Fining Anthony Calvillo sends a message that no one's above the law.

The CFL announced fines for three players Wednesday evening, and there was a surprising name topping the list; Montreal Alouettes quarterback Anthony Calvillo. You wouldn't expect Calvillo to be receiving discipline from the league; the 39-year-old CFL career passing leader has long been a class act on and off the field, and even if he wasn't, quarterbacks are more frequently in the news for suffering dirty hits than delivering them. However, in this case, the fine for Calvillo's perfectly justified, as he tried to trip Edmonton linebacker Rod Williams in the Alouettes' blowout win over the Eskimos Friday. Williams picked off Calvillo, and rather than go for a standard tackle, Calvillo lunged at the linebacker with his right leg, as you can see in the video below:

The effect's more comic than anything, as Calvillo missed and Williams went on to return the ball much further before being brought down, but that's still a dangerous play. Tackling itself causes enough perils; attempted tripping of an opponent this way, especially at full speed with a fully-extended leg, could result in serious injury for either player involved. It didn't in this case, so this isn't deserving of a suspension, but a fine here sends a couple of important messages. For one thing, it makes it clear that the league doesn't operate under the no harm, no foul principle; sure, plays that actually cause injuries are more likely to result in suspension, but even plays that didn't actually hurt anyone like this deserve to be be punished to discourage others from trying them.

On another front, this helps alleviate the perception that the league will only go after specific players for stepping outside the rules; if Calvillo can be fined, anyone can be, and that might help to encourage safer play. It also makes it clear that offensive skill players are accountable for their on-field actions, too, not just linemen and hard-hitting defenders. Safety's a critical issue for the CFL, and that's why discipline matters so much; it's important to see the league won't stand for dangerous plays like like the one Calvillo made and the ones Toronto defenders Brandon Isaac and Marcus Ball were also fined for Wednesday (in their case, the issue was illegal hits on Calgary running back Jon Cornish). Fining Calvillo (one day before his 40th birthday, too) illustrates that the league's ready and willing to hold anyone accountable, and that's a positive move that might just help make the game safer on the whole.

(Update: this post mistakenly identified the Edmonton defender as Rod Davis, the former Esks' LB who's now with Montreal. It was Rod Williams.)

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (13)
  • City paid price for poor finishing against Juventus - Toure

    City paid price for poor finishing against Juventus - Toure

    Manchester City paid the price for their lack of killer instinct in front of goal in Wednesday's 1-0 loss to Italian champions Juventus in the Champions League, midfielder Yaya Toure has said. The Sky Blues let their fate slip out of their hands on … More »

    Reuters - 9 minutes ago
  • Disney's ESPN subscribers fall over 3 percent

    (Reuters) - Walt Disney Co's sports network ESPN saw a 3.2 percent fall in subscribers from the previous fiscal year, in a market where viewers are migrating to newer forms of sports coverage. The number of ESPN subscribers fell to 92 million as at … More »

    Reuters - 10 minutes ago
  • Tighe thrives as Sydney winds flummox Spieth and Co

    Tighe thrives as Sydney winds flummox Spieth and Co

    By Nick Mulvenney SYDNEY (Reuters) - Unheralded local Lincoln Tighe upstaged a field including world number one Jordan Spieth and a string of major winners after swirling winds wreaked havoc on the opening round of the Australian Open on Thursday. … More »

    Reuters - 12 minutes ago
  • Spieth 5 back in Australia after 71

    Spieth 5 back in Australia after 71

    Jordan Spieth and Adam Scott struggled to even-par 71s in the hot, windy opening round of the Australian Open on Thursday, leaving the top two-ranked players in the tournament five strokes behind little-known leader Lincoln Tighe. Spieth and Scott, … More »

    AP - Sports - 24 minutes ago
  • BRIEF-Shenzhen Grandland Decoration to invest in Guangzhou Evergrande Taobao Football Club

    Nov 26 (Reuters) - Shenzhen Grandland Decoration Group CoLtd * Says plans to invest 150 million yuan ($23.48 million) inGuangzhou Evergrande Taobao Football Club Source text in Chinese: http://bit.ly/1ljaIjQ Further company coverage: ($1 = 6.3891 … More »

    Reuters - 27 minutes ago