What's buzzing:

55 Yard Line

Are the Blue Bombers going to retain interim head coach Tim Burke for 2013? Should they?

Andrew Bucholtz
55 Yard Line

View photo


Has Bombers interim head coach Tim Burke done enough to earn the full job?

Gary Lawless of The Winnipeg Free Press had an interesting piece Monday, saying that the Blue Bombers were set to take the "interim" off of head coach Tim Burke's job title and that "his return as head coach is almost automatic." Since then, Burke's said that he hasn't been in discussions with the team about his future, so an announcement may not be quite that imminent. However, there are real questions about if the team should be so set to jump on board with Burke just yet.

Yes, the Bombers have had some impressive victories under Burke, including this past week's 44-32 road win over Toronto. Yes, despite being 5-11, they're still in playoff contention. However, the team hasn't unequivocally improved since the switch to Burke. Sure, the Bombers were 2-6 before head coach Paul LaPolice was fired, and they're 3-5 since. That doesn't necessarily mean that Burke is a better coach or that he's improved the team. Let's look at the picture in a bit of a more comprehensive fashion than just adding up the records. First, consider the results each coach has recorded by score:

Yep, that's right. Despite winning one more game than LaPolice over the same number of contests, Burke's average result has been a loss by 10.6 points. By contrast, LaPolice's average result was a loss by 8.5 points. Sure, margin of victory comes with its own disclaimers (a topic I discussed with Rob Pettapiece on the CIS front this week), but it can still be a useful stat when used in the proper context. One interesting way to do so is to consider the number of close losses.

It's obviously a bit of a debate exactly what's close, but let's look at these coaches' losses within a touchdown (a loss by seven points or less): LaPolice has two (both by three points), while Burke has one (Week 11's one-point Banjo Bowl loss, which had a lot to do with both an injury to Darian Durant and Burke's own end-game bungling). What about losses within two touchdowns (a loss by 14 points or less), a margin that theoretically gives you a chance with three minutes or less (TD, onside kick, TD)? LaPolice has four of those, while Burke only has two. Blowout losses (above 14 points)? Burke has three, by 52, 41 and 19 points, while LaPolice had two, by 17 and 32 points. Sure, Burke has recorded more actual wins, and those are all that matter in the standings. It's definitely arguable that LaPolice gave his team as many or more chances to win than Burke has, though, and his team was certainly embarrassed less.

Does that mean Burke should be axed? Of course not. The only thing sillier than changing coaches in midseason after a run to the Grey Cup is changing coaches twice in midseason, and Burke should at least get the chance to finish this year. Moreover, many of the issues with the Bombers are on the personnel side, not the coaching side. That brings up another issue, though; the team has to decide whether to keep general manager Joe Mack or go in a different direction, and you probably want to let either Mack or his replacement have input on who's coaching the team.

In Burke's defence, his team has looked better lately. Two of their three wins in his tenure have come in the last three weeks.  He also seems to be adapting to the head coaching job (a role he'd never held at a high level before this season), and this isn't to say that he's doomed to fail. The point here is just that it might be a little premature to go anointing Burke as a Mike Rileyesque franchise saviour, especially before the team plays its final two regular-season games. Despite the hype, what he's accomplished to date isn't really much better on balance than what the coach they already fired this season did.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (2)
  • Mourinho tells Chelsea they can sack him but he's not quitting

    Mourinho tells Chelsea they can sack him but he's not quitting

    By Clare Lovell LONDON (Reuters) - With as much bravado as he could muster, a grim-faced Jose Mourinho said he would not walk out of Chelsea despite his champions suffering their fourth defeat in eight Premier League matches and languishing 16th in … More »

    Reuters - 4 minutes 27 seconds ago
  • Chelsea crash again as Aguero hits five for Man City

    Chelsea crash again as Aguero hits five for Man City

    By Mike Collett LONDON (Reuters) - Chelsea's early season slump turned into a full-blown crisis on Saturday when they were beaten 3-1 by Southampton while Manchester City went top of the Premier League with Sergio Aguero scoring five in a 6-1 win … More »

    Reuters - 5 minutes ago
  • Sevilla send Barca to second straight away defeat

    Sevilla send Barca to second straight away defeat

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA (Reuters) - Champions Barcelona suffered their second defeat in three matches in La Liga on Saturday with Michael Krohn-Dehli scoring and setting up another goal in a 2-1 victory for Sevilla. Denmark international … More »

    Reuters - 7 minutes ago
  • DeGale to defend IBF super middleweight belt against Bute

    LONDON (AP) -- James DeGale will make the first defense of his IBF world super middleweight title against former champion Lucian Bute in the challenger's home country of Canada on Nov. 28. … More »

    AP - Sports - 9 minutes ago
  • Australia send England tumbling out of the World Cup

    Australia send England tumbling out of the World Cup

    By Nick Mulvenney LONDON (Reuters) - Australia sent England tumbling into the Rugby World Cup abyss on Saturday when they demolished the hosts 33-13 at Twickenham to ensure the 2003 champions would take no further part in their own tournament after … More »

    Reuters - 10 minutes ago