Puck Daddy - NHL

Today is the 50th anniversary of Jacques Plante strapping on a goalie mask in a game against the New York Rangers at Madison Square Garden, which is remembered by Stan Fischler in a Hockey News piece.

The commemoration has given us some really inspired looks at goalie masks, from Stu Hackel's in-depth piece on Plante for the New York Times to Elliotte Friedman's Inside Hockey report about mask painting on "Hockey Night in Canada" to TSN's amusing fan vote on the best mask in the NHL today.

It's worthy celebration, because the goalie mask is fascinating aspect of hockey culture that has -- like hat-tricks and slap-shots -- seeped into different genres of popular culture.

But that doesn't even begin to mine the depths of the goalie mask's peculiar juxtaposition with the sport from which it was born. Its existence is a fascinating contrast with the established doctrines and perceptions of professional hockey, and flies in the face of those of professional sports as well.

From the moment Plante donned one to protect his injured mug -- check out more about Plante on The Copper & Blue -- the goalie mask has been an essential piece of safety equipment in hockey. Seeing a goaltender wear one is to be reminded instantly that rubber pucks flying at speeds in excess of 100 mph are tiny black agents of maiming.

But masks don't look like shoulder pads or shin guards or anything other piece of equipment that serves to protect. Over the years, they've become personalized statements of artistry.

They reveal something psychologically about the man behind the mask, whether it's Vesa Toskala's(notes) desire to be ferocious or Martin Brodeur's(notes) conservative understatement or Ray Emery's(notes) love of pugilism. In the case of Chris Osgood(notes) of the Detroit Red Wings, his no-frills mask reflects his flash-less, blue collar approach.

Like a tattoo or a sticker on a car, they tell us everything from a players' attitude to his pop culture preferences: Kari Lehtonen's(notes) Heath Ledger-as-the-Joker, Patrick Lalime's(notes) Marvin the Martian and Steve Valiquette's Spider-Man tributes immediately come to mind.

(Again, for these masks in all their glory, head to TSN. And check out The Goalies Archive for more.)

This evolution is absolutely stunning in the context of "team first," "it's the logo on the front not the name on the back" hockey culture. Players who appear to self-promote are frequently lambasted by the establishment as "putting themselves before the team," and yet Jason LaBarbara will probably be known as the guy with Eddie Vedder, Metallica and the Ultimate Warrior on his mask by as many people who know him as the Phoenix Coyotes' backup goalie with nary a criticism.

(From In Goal Magazine.) 

The goalie mask is also something unique to hockey. The NFL would disband a franchise that allowed its quarterback that level of personalization on his helmet. MLB catchers aren't exactly putting a pirate maiden on their masks like Mike Smith(notes) has for the Tampa Bay Lightning. The NBA comes closest to personalization, with headbands and sneakers and high socks; but the tattoos basically take care of that aspect of the game (if the dunk celebrations don't).

There's no other piece of athletic equipment that so perfectly captures the distinctive aspects of its sport: The need for protection against the brutality of the game; its inherent artistry amidst that brutality; and the struggle between individuality and the anonymity of competing in what is a true team sport.

But beyond the sociological aspects of the mask is an widely accepted truth:

They're just bitchin' cool.

That's why they've become symbolic and iconic in pop culture, from Casey Jones from "TMNT" to machete-wielding monsters to every hockey movie ever made.

Spots Illustrated pointed out the Hollywood-zation of the mask in a visual tribute to hockey "frights" -- the Thunder City Bombers goalie from "Youngblood"; Denis Lemieux "Slap Shot"; this incredible mask worn by Jeff Anderson's in Kevin Smith's "Zack and Miri Make a Porno"; and, of course, Jason Voorhees "Friday the 13th."

People forget that Jason started out as a homicidal maniac wearing a sack over his head, sort of like the Scarecrow from Batman. He upgraded to goalie gear and ... well, let's just say that "Friday The 13th burlap sack" isn't one of the best-selling Halloween costumes of the last three decades.

Put on a goalie mask, and you're going to get attention. Which is one of the reasons why their future in the NHL is intriguing, because they're basically billboards for the players who wear them ... so why not for the advertisers that support the League?

We've already heard that goalies want in on the commercialization of hockey gear, feeling their equipment lends itself to NASCAR-style (OK, Euro hockey-style) logos and slogans.

If the sweater remains off-limits for sponsorship, what about the lid? We've already seen the Tampa Bay Lightning turn their goalie masks into movie posters, right?

If the 'tenders are serious about increasing their revenue streams, this could be an interesting compromise and/or battle with the NHL on the horizon.

But that's down the line. For now, let's celebrate the singular joys of the modern hockey mask. What's your favorite one in current circulation? And will we ever seen anything that comes close to the awesomeness that was Gilles Gratton's?

digg delicious
more

43 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. habs1rule
    1. Posted by habs1rule Sun Nov 01, 2009 3:48 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Gilles Gratton mask will live in infamy ...Doug Favell "Starburst" set the standard years ago, simple, color coordinated, and just plain nice!!
  2. HotStacey
    2. Posted by HotStacey Sun Nov 01, 2009 3:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    woah!! annother ONE to ZERO BARN BURNER! three cheers for the nhl on that one. their "feature" presentation for sunday and it ends ONE.......to ZERO. soccer has arrived. 03-04 is without ANY question back in full force.
  3. Scotty Hockey
    3. Posted by Scotty Hockey Sun Nov 01, 2009 4:34 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Stacey - it was 1-0 but after the first period, it was quite an exciting game. And, if you want to hold on to your soccer comparison, that sport happens to be the most popular in the world. So suck it.
    Wysh - Hank and Valley wore special masks for today's warmups, with Valley wearing a Mike Richter replica and Hank with a JD take off that included one of Jacques Plante's ears. It was amazing. Highly recommend checking them out if photos surface ...
  4. JonB
    4. Posted by JonB Sun Nov 01, 2009 4:50 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Stacey, did you really expect a 5-4 shootout? These are two teams struggling offensively, with all-star caliber goaltenders, and solid defense. Not exactly the recipe for a scorefest. Besides, there was a lot of physical play, and plenty of quality scoring chances.
    Not everything in hockey has to be goal-scoring. If you want tons of goals, watch handball.
  5. big audio
    5. Posted by big audio Sun Nov 01, 2009 4:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Newsday back in the day printed a color picture of Gratton's mask (he was on the Rangers) and I cut it out and I still have it. It was INCREDIBLE. Best mask EVER, by FAR. Secondary prizes to Gerry Cheevers', those stitchmarks were awesome too.
  6. habs1rule
    6. Posted by habs1rule Sun Nov 01, 2009 5:05 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Hot Spacey. Try Pinball., lots of scoring, red flashing lights too!!
  7. joe h
    7. Posted by joe h Sun Nov 01, 2009 6:09 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    That game was exciting what the hell are you talking about
  8. 88
    8. Posted by 88 Sun Nov 01, 2009 8:08 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Ray Emery's tribute to boxing legends my current fave.
    Any discussion of hockey masks has to include Kenny Dryden's iconic first mask that thousands of Canadian youngsters would spend hours trying to draw in art class back in the 70's like this Canadian. Even though of course it was my duty as a Leaf lover to loathe the Montreal Canadiens that mask was freakin' cool!
  9. Ogre39666
    9. Posted by Ogre39666 Sun Nov 01, 2009 8:31 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    @ Hot Stacey:
    You should check out Tiddly Winks and Skee-Ball too; tons of scoring there.
    @ Everyone else:
    As far as active masks go, you'd be hard pressed to find any more artistic than Huet's headdress or Miller's abstract buffalo head.
  10. campbellmcdonald32
    10. Posted by campbellmcdonald32 Sun Nov 01, 2009 9:09 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Today's goalie masks blow almost as much as 1-0 games.
    Maybe today's battle wasn't as boring as all that, but Stacey's point remains valid: we are very nearly back to pre-lockout hockey where the big man dominates, system hockey rules, and scoring is as rare as striking oil.
    Hockey honks should spend a day watching other sports. It's amazing how unwatchable hockey is right now. That first post-lockout season where the Sabres and Hurricanes skated circles around everybody seems like a dream of Bobby Ewing-like proportions.
  11. sabre3011
    11. Posted by sabre3011 Sun Nov 01, 2009 9:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I got to say I really like Miller's mask . . . but I'm probably biased. :)
  12. E = MC Hammer
    12. Posted by E = MC Hammer Sun Nov 01, 2009 9:24 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Bring back Ray Emery's Mike Tyson mask.
  13. Johnny Appleseed
    13. Posted by Johnny Appleseed Sun Nov 01, 2009 9:50 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    @11: Part of the reason for the lack of scoring right now has been the unusual glut of injuries to premier scorers in the NHL. Here's a quick list of players that are currently injured: Kovalchuk, Savard, Lucic, Cole, Hossa, Tucker, Modano, Franzen, Comrie, Souray, Booth, Markov, Spezza, Briere, Gagne, Malkin, Gonchar, Oshie, Steen, Kessel, Sedin, Demitra, and now potetially Ovechkin.
    That's a quality line-ups worth of players, most of whom are out at least a month. No wonder scoring is down.
  14. Stonebutcher51
    14. Posted by Stonebutcher51 Sun Nov 01, 2009 10:15 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Who was the goalie who painted all of his facial scars on his mask years ago?
  15. macmike86
    15. Posted by macmike86 Sun Nov 01, 2009 10:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I'm both "Old School and just plain OLD. I always loved Jerry Cheevers " surgical stitches" mask. I grew up in Chicago and loved the extremely simple mask of Tony Esposito, but it was TONY "O" so it was extremely cool.
  16. LordStanleyx2
    16. Posted by LordStanleyx2 Sun Nov 01, 2009 10:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I always liked the 'Thunder Bay Bombers' goalie's mask from 'Youngblood' with Rob Lowe and Swayze!
  17. ranndino
    17. Posted by ranndino Sun Nov 01, 2009 10:55 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "50 Years Behind the Mask" special on NHL Network was fascinating. Highly recommend catching that. Was super cool to see how the modern masks are made and the evolution from the very primitive one Jacque Plante wore.
    Also, man... old time coaches were complete jerks to protest goalies wearing masks even after terrible facial injuries. The whole macho crap reminds me of the current debate about mandatory shields.
  18. duntrune1
    18. Posted by duntrune1 Sun Nov 01, 2009 11:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, Cheever's mask was a classic, but I LOVED Steve Shields' replica of it when he was with the B's, and back of Cheevers head and hair were on the back of the mask it was brilliant...
  19. Osama
    19. Posted by Osama Sun Nov 01, 2009 11:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Who was the goalie that had a fairly simple mask, but had the 3 Stanley Cups painted on the back? That says it all.
  20. livingston county
    20. Posted by livingston county Mon Nov 02, 2009 12:41 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Growing up, I remember Tim Cheveldae having the Corvette and Chevy logo on it.......sweeeeeeeeeeet.
  21. jeradp
    21. Posted by jeradp Mon Nov 02, 2009 12:52 am EST

    Report Abuse

    It's Eddie VEDDER, not Veddar, dip [profane]
  22. max p
    22. Posted by max p Mon Nov 02, 2009 2:25 am EST

    Report Abuse

    If it wasn't for hockey masks, Casey Jones and Jason would not be so cool.
  23. mattw
    23. Posted by mattw Mon Nov 02, 2009 3:20 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Gerry Cheevers had the best mask ever Boston bruin hall of famer, added new stitches every time he took head shot
  24. goaltender41
    24. Posted by goaltender41 Mon Nov 02, 2009 6:29 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Gerry Cheevers' mask - best all-time.
    Honorable mention to Doug Favell, who was the first to wear a painted mask. It was a Halloween joke by his trainer - who painted Favell's mask orange to look like a pumpkin.
    Craig Anderson's Yeti-in-a-Goalie-Mask is the best of the current crop. There is a trend to the simpler recently that is a breath of fresh air in all the airbrush fumes. I love Marty Turco, but his designs are so busy and metallic, you can't see it clearly.
    The "tribute" mask is big this year - Khabibulin, Deslauriers, McDonald, and Biron, in addition to Valiquette and Lundqvist; all very cool.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers