Mon Nov 02, 2009 12:59 pm EST
I
didn't include the Green Bay Packers in yesterday's
Cry, Whine and Moan feature, because I felt like it was a special kind of
loss that deserved its own post.
Not that it was the most painful loss of all-time or anything, but it was certainly unique in how it was painful. Most of us will never see our hero, arguably the best player in the history of our franchise, come back in the colors of our arch-rival and then destroy us, cementing the fact that his new football team is now clearly better than his old one.
That just doesn't happen. Not on this level, with a player of that magnitude, between rivals so bitter.
I feel bad for Packers fans. Not because of who I blame for anything that's happened -- blame doesn't really matter anymore. Blame Brett Favre(notes), Ted Thompson, global warming or Emmanual Lewis if you really want to. No matter who's at fault, Packers fans just suffered a loss that packed some serious sting. Forty-five% say it's the toughest loss Packers fans have ever had to deal with.
Karma failed us. After everything that's happened, all the breathless media reports, all the spin, all the lies, all the hurt feelings ... Brett Favre gets to come out on top, both times? This time, in your own front yard? That is not right. That is not just.
Packers fans deserved to win at least one of those games, and it seems cruel that they didn't get to. All they got was to see Favre leaving their field, with his hands raised high in victory.
I guess "deserve" is a concept that doesn't apply here, though. Things happened the way they did because Minnesota has a better football team. They have a better defense and a better running attack. In this case, that means they win. It sucks, but that's how it works.
The reaction in Green Bay today seems surprisingly pragmatic, though. The Packers blogs are worried about things like their head coach, Aaron Rodgers, Johnny Jolly, and Dom Capers (naughty language alert for that last one). Like pretty much every other team out there. The newspapers are a little more Favre-y, but there's just as much focus on things like Cullen Jenkins roasting Dom Capers, and the differences in the rest of the Green Bay and Minnesota rosters.
I'm sure there's a lot of frustration and anger behind all that, too. You have my sympathies, Packer fans. No group of fans should have to go through that, and then get denied satisfaction twice.
Other popular football stories on Yahoo! Sports:
• Boneheaded plays and players from this week’s NFL action
• Controversy: Star gets heat for dirty eye-gouging play
• Historic collapse by perennial college powerhouse
Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Police: Dog kicked to death before Steelers game
Posted Nov 23 2009
Are NFL players hiding concussions?
Posted Nov 19 2009
Posted Nov 19 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
1248 Comments
1 - 25 of 1248
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
But to apologize to GB Fans. Did you read any of the blogs prior to the game? My God, "We are gonna bury Favre in Lambeau dirt", I could go on and on. Packer fans got what they deserved, a loss at the hands of a better team with a better QB. (Rodgers will be a real force in the div for a long time, he's young, I admit).
MJD needs to fly to GB and just get the whole cry-a-thon over with.
In August I got an email from an old flame who's a Packer fan. It had a photo of Favre and the words "MN: Where old qb's go to die". I saved it, and returned it yesterday after letting the playing of the game say it all.
You should try that.
Report Abuse
But to apologize to GB Fans. Did you read any of the blogs prior to the game? My God, "We are gonna bury Favre in Lambeau dirt", I could go on and on. Packer fans got what they deserved, a loss at the hands of a better team with a better QB. (Rodgers will be a real force in the div for a long time, he's young, I admit).
MJD needs to fly to GB and just get the whole cry-a-thon over with.
In August I got an email from an old flame who's a Packer fan. It had a photo of Favre and the words "MN: Where old qb's go to die". I saved it, and returned it yesterday after letting the playing of the game say it all.
You should try that.
Report Abuse
That pretty much sums everything up. I really feel bad now.
Report Abuse
Hell, with a roster most people laughed at with NO running game until week 8 when Ryan Grant came along, Favre turned in a 13-3 season. Favre is the BEST QB of all time, yes, better than Montana, Young, Marino, Elway, etc. WHY? Because he did MORE than those guys... with LESS talent around him. Favre didn't have an Emmitt Smith, or a Jerry Rice and still put up numbers. And then they BOO him... in HIS house... if it wasn't for Favre the Packers are NO ONE for the last 16 years...
Report Abuse
just because he had a tearful retirement conference doesn't mean anything. green bay fans are the most classless jerks ever. if anything, they should be booing ted thompson for being a dumbass.
the guy gave his blood for the team for 16 years, never missing a game. that's old-school professionalism.
i got brett's back. he's an american icon and the sort of american hero that has become extinct in the 21st century.
Report Abuse
not to mention ryan grant immediately was exposed to be a fraud when rodgers took over.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Management got rid of him because he's no longer a great big game QB, or even average one, during the play offs.
1 - 25 of 1248