Dr. Saturday - NCAAF

In the span of a little less than a month, the SEC has gradually devolved into the Twilight Zone where the league's officiating is concerned, culminating this week with the legitimate possibility of Urban Meyer, respected, championship-winning coach of the No. 1 team in the country, being fined or suspended by the conference for publicly criticizing a non-call on a hit against his star quarterback. How on earth did the Chosen Conference back itself into this corner?

Here's a short timeline of all hell breaking loose:

Oct. 3: Officials threw two ridiculous flags for illegal celebration following successive touchdowns by Georgia's A.J. Green and LSU's Charles Scott in the final two minutes of the Tigers' dramatic win in Athens:

The call against Green, in particular, drew enough heat to force the league to issue a public mea culpa admitting that Green's celebration didn't warrant a flag. (It was silent, oddly, on the equally bogus flag against Scott.)

Oct. 17: After a quiet week (CBS' nationally televised game on Oct. 10 was Alabama's wholly uncontroversial, 22-3 beatdown at Ole Miss), the same officiating crew that drew so much scrutiny at Georgia two weeks earlier flung itself back in the kiln with a series of sketchy calls on an eventual Florida touchdown drive to tie Arkansas at 20 in the fourth quarter of the Gators' last-second, 23-20 escape, particularly phantom pass interference and unnecessary roughness calls against the Razorbacks in a span of three plays:

Feeling accountable to fans to uphold its "integrity," the conference summarily suspended the crew for three weeks, specifically citing the "lack of evidence" for a flag on the unnecessary roughness call against Malcolm Sheppard. Some pundits applaud the move for its transparency and responsiveness; other (ahem) suggested repeatedly undermining officials in public would open a Pandora's box that opened every routine bad call to a round of criticism and mini-scandal, and that retribution and acknowledgment of mistakes should remain behind closed doors, through private channels. The conference also reprimanded Arkansas coach Bobby Petrino for publicly criticizing the same bogus calls that the head office itself had just publicly deemed worthy of suspension.

Oct. 24: Officials in Florida's win over Mississippi State fail to overturn a Gator touchdown despite an obvious fumble by UF's Dustin Doe before he crosses the goal line, and also fail to throw a flag on Alabama's Terrence Cody for tossing his helmet after blocking Tennessee's game-winning field goal attempt at the gun, though the ball was still in play. Both MSU coach Dan Mullen and Tennessee coach Lane Kiffin publicly criticize the no-calls; both are swiftly reprimanded by the league office. Tennessee assistant Ed Orgeron and Vanderbilt coach Bobby Johnson both take public shots at the refs, too, but don't draw any response from the conference. (Maybe if Vandy's loss at South Carolina had been on national television ...)

Commissioner Mike Slive, tired of the sudden spate of belly-aching from his coaches, swears off warnings and reprimands in favor of an immediate fine or suspension the first time any SEC coach dares to criticize the officials for anything.

Oct. 31: Florida's Brandon Spikes gets a little dirty against Georgia's Washaun Ealey in a pile-up:

The obvious personal foul went unnoticed by officials in the game and likely would have gone unnoticed, period, if not for the alert zooming of CBS' cameras, which helped turn a rather forgettable 15-yard penalty in an uncompetitive game into the SEC officiating scandal du jour. Dragged under by the rising tide of suspensions, Florida vowed to sit its star for the first half this Saturday against Vanderbilt; facing added backlash for perceived leniency, Spikes volunteered to sit for the entire game. (What a guy.)

But let's go to the tape! Was Spikes poked in the eye himself? Was Ealey playing dirty, too? Did Georgia hit Tim Tebow late with no repercussions? How can you single out one dirty play in a game chock-full of them?

That's what Urban Meyer wants to know, specifically regarding an alleged late hit by UGA's Nick Williams against Tebow:

"That should have been a penalty in my opinion. Obviously it should have been. You've got to protect quarterbacks. That's the whole purpose. It's right in front of the referee.''

As Kiffin was quick to point out Wednesday -- and he would know, obviously -- that's a violation, Urban. (And p.s.: You may be wrong about the rule, anyway.)

So here is the end result of "transparency" when it comes to policing bad calls: Two days before one of the biggest games of the season, everyone who follows the SEC is consumed instead by poring over run-of-the-mill "cheap shots" on obscure plays from a ame that ended five days ago and wondering whether or not the conference actually has the guts to drop the hammer on its most visible, most successful and highest-paid coach. Over a comment he made at a press conference about a play barely anyone would have ever remembered in a game that was decided by 24 points.

This is stupid. It's been stupid from the beginning -- as bad calls go, every play in question over the last month is fairly routine, exactly the kind of familiar griping and frustrated sniping that goes on after close losses as a matter of course. (As opposed to a truly egregious killer like the Fifth Down or the Oregon-Oklahoma onside kick in 2006 or, if you think it was a bad call -- I don't -- the pass interference flag that kept Ohio State alive in overtime against Miami in the 2003 Fiesta Bowl.) In the end, none of the bad calls in the SEC this year directly affected the outcome of a game. None of them resulted in an injury. These were ordinary mistakes, the kind officials have been making (and will continue to make) for decades, and that fans gripe about for a couple days and move on. The extraordinary media reaction, in the current environment, might have been expected. But for the SEC to voluntary and unnecessarily open a box that it can only close by fining or suspending Urban Meyer is stupid. And it's too late to turn back now: Either Meyer gets what's coming to him or the lid is blown wide open to non-stop complaints about anything and everything for the rest of the season. This is exactly what the league asked for when it decided to repeatedly, publicly acknowledge ordinary mistakes in the first place.

In the meantime, the WAC has suspended a replay official for a bad call in Boise State's 45-7 win over San Jose State. Good luck with that, guys.

digg delicious
more

77 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. piecesofship
    1. Posted by piecesofship Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    coady's helmet removal and the arkansas' calls probably directly influenced the winner of the said games.
  2. Pete
    2. Posted by Pete Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What about the Charles Scott celebration penalty was bogus, exactly? You can't run to the crowd and point at them. That's going to get you flagged every single time. It's a stupid rule, but it was enforced correctly on that play.
  3. timjames99
    3. Posted by timjames99 Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The fine is the easiest way for Slive to save face, then perhaps a conference call pleading with coaches to quiet down for the rest of the year before the conference they play in (and earn their money from indirectly) becomes a train wreck.
  4. John V
    4. Posted by John V Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:46 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Gee I'm so sad the SEC is going through this. Bwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
  5. Mike
    5. Posted by Mike Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:07 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Time for the NCAA to create a centralized pool of officials for all of football. That way the conferences are out of the mix and any perceived favoritism is gone. Train these officials like the NFL does with theirs.
  6. PurdueMatt
    6. Posted by PurdueMatt Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:15 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    That pass interference call late in the Florida/Arkansas game was the worst of all.
  7. PurdueMatt
    7. Posted by PurdueMatt Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:16 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    2 wrongs don't make a right, Spikes is a jackass. Voluntarily sitting out the entire game is a selfish move to make it all about him.
  8. Nicoleta
    8. Posted by Nicoleta Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:16 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    @Mike
    The NFL does such a good job with officiating that it would be completely moronic for the NCAA to not copy their system. Please detect the sarcasm
  9. Dan
    9. Posted by Dan Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I agree 100 percent. The SEC made a horrible decision in making public statements and have fed the paranoia of coaches and fans who don't want to accept the outcome of the game.
  10. peoplespigskin
    10. Posted by peoplespigskin Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:27 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Matt, I admire your work, but I have to disagree with your assertion that "none of the bad calls in the SEC this year directly affected the outcome of a game." The three calls against Arkansas allowed Florida to keep alive a drive that would prove to be the difference between winning and losing. Throwing a flag against Terrence Cody would have given Tennessee a chance to kick another field goal (at much closer range, thanks to the 15 yards) to upset Alabama. Those decisions, however we may feel about the rules involved, affected the outcomes of two games just as much as the Fifth Down. And for the conspiracy theorists out there, there's the bonus of keeping Florida and Alabama undefeated, allowing the SEC to turn its championship game into a de facto national semifinal.
    I'm not saying I agree with how the SEC handled its officiating woes, and I'm not saying I like the rules that were invoked or ignored in these cases. But the SEC couldn't pretend that nothing happened, either.
  11. Carl V
    11. Posted by Carl V Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:27 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    @ PurdueMatt:
    Really? Not playing, at all, will make it all about him? You don't think the media hounding him, non stop, for it might have anything to do with it? Or maybe regret? Shame? Disappointment?
    How on earth does it draw MORE attention to him? If anything, the entire point is to make it LESS about him!
  12. just4funsies
    12. Posted by just4funsies Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:33 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What is ALSO stupid is that the media (including the idiot bloggers) continue to beat this dead horse. Like the saying goes, EVERYBODY has an opinion. We know what they are, been there, done that... Let's MOVE ON, ALREADY. If people keep either jumping to conclusions at the first opportunity or microscopically examining EVERY little detail looking for controversy, then they might as well play the games, everybody goes home, and THEN the NCAA can announce two weeks later who actually WON. Enough! Jeezus!
  13. genius_man16
    13. Posted by genius_man16 Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:59 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    You can't forget, if the SEC doesn't penalize Urban Meyer, the outcry of favoritism will be too big to ignore.
  14. Rock
    14. Posted by Rock Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Matt,
    Check your facts. Cody's helmet removal was not a penalty. The national media lost track of the official ruling apparently and took Gary Danielson's on-air word for it. On an aside, Danielson did apologize publicly the following Monday for speaking about a ruling that he was incorrect on.
    Thanks,
    Rock
  15. steelers suck
    15. Posted by steelers suck Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:06 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Listen get off of floridas c o c k give me a break these guys maybe play 2 or 3 good teams a year how r they still ranked number one tebow is a joke he will never never never make it in the nfl and to the guy tht gouges eyes under the pile way to show ur true colors nothing but a fake a s s thug wanna be u r a punk a s s and always will be what a joke give it up media get off the florida d i c k plz
  16. joshuagammerman
    16. Posted by joshuagammerman Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:22 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Matt.....here's a horse....
    by god, I think its dead.....
    I tell you what, lets just beat the sh*t out of it for awhile
  17. Ancient Chinese Secret
    17. Posted by Ancient Chinese Secret Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:33 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I'm usually pretty skeptical when people claim that the fix is in regarding a game involving their team, but man does this look bad when you put it all together. When you add in the "officiating" in the Indiana-Iowa game, it's hard not to think that conferences are actively trying to protect their undefeated teams, especially at the expense of the traditional conference bottom-dwellers. I think a lot of the poor officiating in CFB is due to the use of non-professional officals, but you have to wonder if the NCAA would replace conference-paid refs with some sort of centralized officiating system to at lead avoid the apparence of impropriety, if not corrupt officiating itself.
  18. Zach
    18. Posted by Zach Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:52 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Matt: The 5th down was a complete non-issue, as CU's QB spiked the ball on 3rd down (actually 4th) to talk over the 4th down play. CU would obviously not spike the ball if the down marker read 4th down, so whether that play affected the end result is debatable and not cut-and-dry as you presuppose.
    Go Buffs 1990 Nat'l Champs,
    Wooo Hooo
  19. Anthony B
    19. Posted by Anthony B Thu Nov 05, 2009 5:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    If you count the Arkansas penalties as plays, they actually bring down the YPP (12.5 without, 11.25 with) on that drive. Ergo, no effect.
  20. Big Jim
    20. Posted by Big Jim Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    . Posted by piecesofship Thu Nov 05--- actually it did not affect the game. The ball had passed the line of scrimmage (LOS) before the helmet came off. That is the same as a punt.... change of possession. The only thing that it changed was Bama didn't get a 15 yard penalty AFTER the change of possession, which does not affect the score at all or the game at all because there was no time remaining and Bama wasn't goint to run a play. Now had the ball not crossed the line of scrimmage, then you got a different situation. But once a field goal crosses the LOS it is the same as a punt... change of posssession and all penalties that occur at that point are POST POSSESSION PENALTIES. So UT would have not gotten a re-kick regardless.
  21. Christiane
    21. Posted by Christiane Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The Ark call did not affect the outcome of the game. It was called on a first down. Had it not been called, Florida would still have had the ball on the ARK 20 yard line.
    I can understand why the SEC decided to have an increased penalty for calling out the ref's integrity. Kiffin's comments implied that the refs were crooked and making sure Bama and UF go to the championship. Obviously you can't have coaches making those comments publicly. Meyer's said they missed a call without inserting a conspiracy theory, so that's why he wasn't punished. I agree with the rule so long as it continues to work along these lines.
  22. Big Jim
    22. Posted by Big Jim Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    While it is fun to argue with people over this stuff... the truth is it doesn't really matter and by next year there will be a new controversy and all this will be forgotten. Human beings are always looking for new dirt and controversy.
  23. ROBERT G
    23. Posted by ROBERT G Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:45 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    we refer to what mike slive and the sec conference and urban meyer and the florida athletic department and saban and the alabama athletic department and the dishonest sec conference game and tech review officials have done and been exposed for this season as premediated economic suicides.
    while we are certainly ready, willing, and able to grant their requests and those of their colleagues in the big 10 and other conferences, we really have to wonder why the member schools in these conferences, who are getting shafted every season by these same con operations, do not simply clean out these con artists running the conferences and dave parry at the ncaa level college football officiating llc themselves.
    the irrefutable evidence is that florida's 2009 team already has 2 real losses, the outcomes of which were altered by dishonest sec officials, that alabama also has 2 losses, the outcomes of which were altered by dishonest sec officials and that iowa also has 2 losses, the outcomes of which were reversed by dishonest big 10 officials.
    we have long passed the point at which the members of the boards of trustees of the schools in these conferences can really be taken seriously by judges and juries if they get up on witness stands at very public civil jury tirals and claim that they did not understand what was going on.
    urban meyer has been around much too long not to know that he and florida have legal obligations volutarily to forfeit those 2 bogus win.
    pretending that these bogus wins never happened also raises significant questions about the christian values which tim tebow claims to live by.
    these phony rigged game outcomes simply are not being accepted by the millions of college football fans all over the us who put up the millions for college football and college sports every season.
    we are now in the high tech internet age and college football and college sports fans simply do not have to take all dogs come with fleas bull [profane] any more.
    the question is no longer whether or not the proprietors of crooked college sports enterprises are going to be back with their same con operations next season since none of them will be.
    the open question is how many coaches, athletic directors, schools, and other people and entities are going to go down with the others because they remained silent and took no action.
  24. TuCkFeBoW
    24. Posted by TuCkFeBoW Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:50 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    10. Posted by peoplespigskin Thu Nov 05, 2009 3:27 pm EST Report Abuse
    Matt, I admire your work, but I have to disagree with your assertion that "none of the bad calls in the SEC this year directly affected the outcome of a game." The three calls against Arkansas allowed Florida to keep alive a drive that would prove to be the difference between winning and losing. Throwing a flag against Terrence Cody would have given Tennessee a chance to kick another field goal (at much closer range, thanks to the 15 yards) to upset Alabama. Those decisions, however we may feel about the rules involved, affected the outcomes of two games just as much as the Fifth Down. And for the conspiracy theorists out there, there's the bonus of keeping Florida and Alabama undefeated, allowing the SEC to turn its championship game into a de facto national semifinal.
    I'm not saying I agree with how the SEC handled its officiating woes, and I'm not saying I like the rules that were invoked or ignored in these cases. But the SEC couldn't pretend that nothing happened, either.
    How true, the sad thing is that all the blind gaytors don't....Their little run is about to be over soon so all we can do now is wait for the NCAA to do thier job and investigate uf's illegal money paying to the recruits and the Degree ATM machines. I'm sure Corrine Brown was one of the first in line...."I just want to gradulate the gator on another BS Championship" -Corrine Brown
  25. TuCkFeBoW
    25. Posted by TuCkFeBoW Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    22. Posted by Christiane Thu Nov 05, 2009 6:28 pm EST Report Abuse
    The Ark call did not affect the outcome of the game. It was called on a first down. Had it not been called, Florida would still have had the ball on the ARK 20 yard line.
    I can understand why the SEC decided to have an increased penalty for calling out the ref's integrity. Kiffin's comments implied that the refs were crooked and making sure Bama and UF go to the championship. Obviously you can't have coaches making those comments publicly. Meyer's said they missed a call without inserting a conspiracy theory, so that's why he wasn't punished. I agree with the rule so long as it continues to work along these lines.
    WRONG! WRONG WRONG! Stop trying to defend something that EVERYONE (besides you blind gaytors) that uf would have still won that game without the help of the refs!! GeezusH! Just stop!

Dr. Saturday

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Matt Hinton

Dr. Saturday is a college football blog edited by Matt Hinton. Email him tips and feedback.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Dr. Saturday Recent Readers