Tue Nov 03, 2009 3:40 pm EST
There's a lot of anger and frustration floating around NASCAR these days. Jimmie Johnson's dominance has robbed the Chase of any bit of drama, leading everyone who's not a fan of the 48 to rage at a system that hasn't produced a different champion in what will likely end up being half a decade.
On top of that, one of the most exciting tracks on the circuit, Talladega, was effectively neutered on Sunday by the last-minute implementation of bump-drafting rules that confused and frustrated the field. It was like going to a beer-and-ribs tailgate and finding only wine coolers and salad -- exactly the wrong kind of race NASCAR needed at this critical moment.
Over at NASCAR.com, Ramsey Poston, NASCAR's director of corporate communications, has written a lengthy blog post defending NASCAR's position at Talladega. And while I don't envy Poston -- he's often in the position of defending his sport against waves of angry fans, as he is now -- he's nonetheless doing a fair amount of cherry-picking in the way he justifies what went down at Talladega.
Poston takes a curious approach here. Rather than conceding even an inch of ground -- "implementing safety measures is an evolving art," or whatever -- Poston places blame squarely on griping drivers, ABC broadcasters ... and you.
Lines like "Love it or hate it, Talladega is about strategy; it's a chess match on wheels and sometimes takes time to develop and play out" seem to imply that this was a good race, and that griping fans were too bloodthirsty or blind to appreciate it. He points to the 13,400-plus passes that took place, according to Loop Data, as an indication that there was indeed action going on at the track -- but apparently, you and ABC missed it.
Here's the thing, though. We've received tons of emails and comments on Talladega in the last few days, and not one -- not one -- took a positive view of Sunday's race. Even ruling out the "people don't write in when they're happy" factor, that's a thorough and definitive rejection of the no-bump-drafting rules and the kind of race they engendered.
Poston goes on to call some of the criticisms of the Talladega race "myths," which isn't quite the word I'd use. Among these "myths":
-There was a "conspiracy" among drivers to run a dull race in response to the no-bump-drafting mandates. Poston points to Jeff Burton, who called such comments "complete nonsense." Was there a planned conspiracy? I don't think so. But I find it very easy to believe that drivers came to the common realization that if they couldn't figure out the parameters of the rules, they'd play extra nice just to make a point, knowing full well that "nice racing" = deadly dull racing.
-Whether NASCAR forced the no-bump-drafting rule on the drivers. Poston contends that the origination of the no-bump-drafting rule came from drivers, not NASCAR itself, saying that "several well-respected veteran drivers" came to NASCAR and said "we need to address the bump-drafting in the corners." That's entirely plausible -- though if those drivers are indeed veteran and well-respected, why haven't they come forward and spoken up? Don't give me the whole "they don't want to seem weak" nonsense; seeing how cars fly around Talladega and wanting very much not to be in a car that leaves the ground isn't weak. I'm not disputing Poston's account, just saying that I would like to get some independent verification from more drivers that they did in fact ask NASCAR for this.
Really, though, my problem isn't with the rules themselves; it's the way they were handed down from on high. The implicit message from NASCAR appeared to be, "we'll tell you if you're doing something wrong -- but if we tell you, it's already too late." NASCAR officials said they wanted to see "sunlight" between the cars -- but does that mean a sliver or three feet? Could go either way, and you don't want any gray area when you're going nearly 200 mph.
-NASCAR doesn't care about safety. This is a straw man for Poston to knock down; of course NASCAR cares about the safety of its drivers and fans. Poston noted that Burton criticized Ryan Newman's comments about NASCAR not caring about the drivers, but I think that was a misinterpretation --Newman was saying that NASCAR doesn't care about the drivers' opinions, not their safety. NASCAR has made tremendous strides in safety; there are half a dozen drivers running out there right now who wouldn't be with us if their wrecks had happened even five years ago.
NASCAR has proven it can make changes to its own rules that will benefit the fan experience; you don't need to look any farther than this year's double-file restarts for that. But Talladega was a PR debacle and a roadkill of a race, and to pretend otherwise -- or, worse, to dismiss those who would criticize it as failing to understand a good race when they see it -- is absolutely the wrong tactic.
In the end, if people don't like a race, all the loop data and assertions to the contrary aren't going to convince them -- and an overwhelming majority did not like this race.
All those seats were empty at Talladega even before the outcome of Sunday's race. NASCAR had better figure a way -- right now -- to fill them back up come spring. Insisting that it's everyone else's fault isn't going to cut it.
From the Marbles is a NASCAR blog edited by Jay Busbee. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Posted Nov 23 2009
Posted Nov 23 2009
Posted Nov 22 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
121 Comments
1 - 25 of 121
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
#1 - NASCAR really needs to quit jacking around with the rules at the last minute with no clarification. I'm not one of the "I'm quitting NASCAR forever (or until next week when I run out of things to complain about)" people, but my thought through most of the race was "Wow, they managed to officially screw up Talladega. Maybe it's time to watch football for the rest of the season."
and
#2 - Thank God they've made some of the safety innovations they have made because I'm pretty sure I didn't breathe for 12 minutes after Newman wrecked and I'm just a fan. I thought there was no way he survived. There have been several of those instances this year and I can think of several drivers that we're lucky we still have.
Bottom line...NASCAR...darned if you do, darned if you don't.
Report Abuse
I don't want to see cars flipping and drivers or spectators getting hurt either, in fact I was very worried that Ryan Newman was injured when I didn't see his window netting come off, but I do want to see RACING, and not just for the last 20-30 minutes of a 3+ hour race. And let's be clear: the drivers want to race as well, I don't doubt that for a moment. So like Jay says, NASCAR better figure it out right quick because otherwise they might as well drop both restrictor plate races off of the calendar if the content is as exciting as Sunday's 'Dega race.
Quite rightly too Jay points out that placing the blame anywhere else is a fools game for NASCAR, ultimately it's their source of revenue and will impact them, the teams and drivers more than anybody else so sticking their head in the sand and pointing fingers elsewhere will only cause them real grief. If they lose numbers, the sponsors will flee, teams will have less money, and NASCAR will end up being the poor country cousin that it used to be.
The open wheel folks are getting their act back together after many years out in the boondocks due to their infighting, so if NASCAR wants to keep my eyeballs and dollars flowing to them, they better take their fans seriously. My interest in motorsports started with open-wheelers and I'm more than happy to go back if the racing there seems more competitive. In fact, on Sunday I missed the beginning of the 'Dega race because I was watching the final F1 race of the season on the PVR. But that would be a shame because it's really only in the last 3-4 years that I've begun to learn and understand some of the subtleties and intricacies of NASCAR style "stock car" racing, although that moniker hardly seems appropriate anymore.
Anyways, good column JB, keep it up!
SJ, Toronto, Canada.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And I agree.
The drivers were nervous about getting black-flagged so they had to let up on the throttle to keep the daylight between each other.
And I don't know about you but not knowing when the guy in front of me is gonna let up at a place where letting up is (supposed to be) a travesty is recipe for disaster, and it was. I'm just thankful the drivers are still alive.
Report Abuse
I have to find out what exactly Burton said before I berate him for being so cavalier about the emotions one experiences after going on the ride that Newman did. Only a drone stripped of all feeling and self preservation would have had anything otherwise to say. Newman only said what he and alot of us thought.
Poston can blow smoke (or Smoke, for that matter) all he wants, but the fact of the matter is that the race sucked.. they made it a flipping sponsor exhibition with a demolition derby ending...only good thing that came of it is that I get to read a lot of articles about Newman this week.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
With Helton's decree Sunday NASCAR has officially "jumped the shark". Without a complete restructure of the organizing body, (Helton being fired immediately like any other sport would do if their president, in the midst of loosing half it's fan base, alienated every fan in attendance of the Superbowl, World Series or NBA Finals) I agree with Jay, that the only race that was guaranteed to be exciting will be a ghost town in 2010.
If NASCAR is going to survive it is time to make it a franchise sport like all the other major leagues. The era of mob control and racetrack monopoly has reached it's crescendo at Talladega. The principle players are in an alternate reality from their fan base and the lack of remorseful acceptance of their actions after Sunday's race should be proof enough.
Report Abuse
SIr...and I use the phrase lightly... you are a dumb-ass!!!
Report Abuse
Hmmmm. When did this happen? during commercials?
Don't you think that ABC was there every step of the way?
Am I missing something here?
Report Abuse
I am so thankful that Ryan and Mark walked away. They may not be my favorite drivers but I would never wish harm or injury to any of the drivers. Obviously Nascar has not reached that point of evolution yet. If your name is Jimmie Johnson you can flip roll smack the wall stand on your nose or whatever. But if you are Jimmie the rest of the world best not touch you even in practice.
Report Abuse
"Poston places blame squarely on griping drivers, ABC broadcasters ... and you." Well, Mr Poston without the drivers, without TV (ABC) and without the fans, you fool... you have nothing!!!!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 121