MLS Playoffs: Goal.com MLS Rankings: Narrow Distinctions

(Note: In my consternation in trying to assemble the rankings this week, I opted for a different approach from the one I used to compile the power rankings last Wednesday and the weekly rankings during the course of the season. In this edition, I have slotted each of the four playoff series from the most likely to turn over [Houston-Seattle] to the least likely to turn over [New England-Chicago] in my estimation. With the fine balance in each of these ties, it's a rough science at best.)

1. New England – After Shalrie Joseph's goal snatched a 2-1 win on Sunday afternoon, the Revs will defend for their lives and attempt to snatch a goal off a set piece in the return leg at Toyota Park. (-)

2. Los Angeles – The Galaxy will look to replicate the latter stages of the first half of Sunday's 2-2 draw rather than the beginning of either stanza. (-)

3. Real Salt Lake – With the Crew's attack stumbling in recent weeks, RSL's best bet to spring an upset may be pressing players into the attack and trying to grab another goal. (-)

4. Houston – In the tightest of the four series, the Dynamo holds the narrowest of advantages after a gritty 0-0 draw at Qwest Field on Thursday. (-)

5. Seattle – Sounders FC's recent road form (4-1-1 in the past six) certainly should give the Dynamo pause. (-)

6. Columbus – The Crew should find a way to break through at Crew Stadium, but can Columbus score enough to avoid the perils of overtime and penalty kicks? (-)

7. Chivas USA
– Speed, speed, speed over the top with a dash of Kljestan and a return to defensive sanity. That's how the Red-and-White should approach the “away” leg. (-)

8. Chicago – The first 20 minutes (and last year's 3-0 second leg playoff win) showed the Fire can rip the Revs apart when required, but Chicago have to cope better with New England's physicality and improve its set piece defending (or avoid conceding them in the first place) to advance to a second consecutive East final. (-)

Kyle McCarthy writes the Monday MLS Breakdown and frequently writes opinion pieces during the week for Goal.com. He also covers the New England Revolution for the Boston Herald and MLSnet.com. Contact him with your questions or comments at kyle.mccarthy@goal.com and follow him on Twitter by clicking here.

For more on Major League Soccer, visit Goal.com's MLS page.

Go to Goal.com for the world’s most comprehensive soccer coverage.

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. superjtron
    6. Posted by superjtron Fri Nov 6 1:51am EST

    Report Abuse

    Here is my solution to MLS playoffs.

    1st place of each conference - bye to the Conference Finals

    2nd place of each conference - bye to the Conference Semifinals

    Remaining top 4 teams regardless of conference are all Wild Cards.

    So 5th best team in MLS plays 8th best team. 6th place plays 7th. One game playoff. Winners advance and play in the Conference Semifinals against one of the 2nd place teams. With the winner of that game advancing to the play the 1st place team in the conference finals. Conference Finals will be a two game series.

    This gives a much greater importance to the regular season. Top teams receive byes and can rest their players while the other teams have to fight it out in earlier rounds. Also ensures that the best teams have a much greater chance to reach the championship.

    Had this been in effect for this season. It would have looked like this.

    8) Real Salt Lake @ 5) Seattle Sounders FC
    7) New England @ 6) Chivas USA

    Conference Semis
    CHV or NE@ Houston Dynamo
    SEA or RSL @ Chicago Fire

    Conference Finals
    LA Galaxy vs. Winner of Semifinals
    Columbus Crew vs. Winner of Semifinals

    Let me know what everyone else thinks!!!!
  2. Monsignor K. Kuwajukaba
    5. Posted by Monsignor K. Kuwajukaba Thu Nov 5 10:43pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Columbus's losss tonight shows a serious problem with MLS.
    Columbus is right now where DC was. When you win back to back supporters shields people take little concern over that. But, lose out on the mls cup and people act as if your team is bad.
    the us open cup and the supporters shield have to be seen by clubs as the real tournament worhty items. Notice how rare it is for the supporters shield winner to win the mls cup.
    no team has yet to win the treble: SS, USOC, MLSC.
    success in the MLS doesn't bring you advantages because the league emphasizes parity. Unfortunately, this means, the better teams are always challenged to be the utmost, and can never have a bad time.

    Look at chicago also. I imagine they will lose the game against new england, which will be too bad for them.
  3. OhStFan
    4. Posted by OhStFan Thu Nov 5 1:02pm EST

    Report Abuse

    It's amazing to me how everyone is counting out the defending champs and the two-time winners of the supporters shield. Columbus will win tonight and go on to successfully defend their title!
  4. Samson
    3. Posted by Samson Wed Nov 4 12:38pm EST

    Report Abuse

    yes move the postseason when the WOrld Series starts, great move for MLS
  5. <i>tyleradams541</i>
    2. Posted by tyleradams541 Tue Nov 3 2:29pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Dynamo singular
  6. HoustonSoccer
    1. Posted by HoustonSoccer Tue Nov 3 10:37am EST

    Report Abuse

    Not much faith in Goal.com's analysis in general and this one in particular. To hike New England to the top implies NE to be the eventual winner - which is way off the map. NE reminds me of Buffalo Bills - been there but only to be second best. Most likely finalists will probably decided in the coming weeks. Teams are a lot closer but expect Dynamos and RSL to be in the picture. Dynamos' because of good ball control and set plays. RSL of persistence.
Sign in to post a comment, or sign up for a free account